We cannot guarantee that the content will display correctly while using Internet Explorer. To have the best browsing experience, please upgrade to Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Safari.

November 7, 2019

Digital Health, Digital Medicine, Digital Therapeutics (DTx): What’s the difference?

Commentary
Digital Medicine Society (DiMe), Digital Therapeutics Alliance (DTA), HealthXL, and NODE.Health
&

Digital Health, Digital Medicine, Digital Therapeutics (DTx): What’s the difference? Clarity matters. Here’s what you need to know

Authors: Jennifer Goldsack, Megan Coder, Chandana Fitzgerald, Natalie Navar-Mattingly, Andy Coravos, and Ashish Atreja, MD

Digital health products have become integral to the prevention, diagnosis, treatment, and management of health and disease. Consumers rely on digital health apps to improve their focus, track their fitness, and optimize their wellbeing. Clinicians use digital health products to gain insights on patient outcomes, conduct telehealth visits, and treat aspects of diseases otherwise unaddressed by traditional medications.

In theory, consumers and clinicians know that there is a difference between these products. But in practice, how do they differentiate between products that accurately collect health information versus those that do not, or those that provide clinicians with informational versus actionable insights?

Not all digital health products are the same. But what are their differences? How should each product be used? What should expectations be about product outcomes? How much evidence is needed to go to market? What type of clinical evidence or regulatory oversight is necessary? 

NICE’s evidence standards framework for digital health technologies and the eHSG (European Commission eHealth Stakeholder Group) Guidance, both released this year, address varying requirements within the digital health universe. With the industry garnering such support, the need to categorize and differentiate between its various solutions becomes even more important.

Providing clarity and trust is crucial in this quickly evolving industry. With this as our mission, the Digital Medicine Society (DiMe), Digital Therapeutics Alliance (DTA), HealthXL, and NODE.Health are collaborating to describe the landscape of digital health products available to end users and clinicians, in addition to the level of clinical evidence and regulatory oversight that correlates to each product category.

As these transformative technologies are laying the groundwork for a new form of healthcare, we must ensure that the digital tools we are placing our trust in are indeed worthy of that trust.

Product risk matters

Digital Health is a broad category that encompasses Digital Medicine, which in turn includes Digital Therapeutics. Products in these categories make different levels of claims and therefore have different levels of risk. As such, they have varying requirements for clinical evidence and regulatory oversight. 

In parallel industries such as transportation, higher levels of research and regulation are required for higher risk functions (e.g., operating autonomous vehicles) than lower risk functions (e.g., bluetooth enabled hands-free car kits). Similarly, end users and clinicians should expect that higher levels of evidence and oversight are required for digital health products that make higher risk claims.

Thus, the Digital Medicine Society (DiMe), Digital Therapeutics Alliance (DTA), HealthXL, and NODE.Health have collaborated to propose this risk-based framework so end users may discern between products of different risk and corresponding levels of necessary evidence and regulatory oversight.

Why categorize the digital health industry?

Rock Health, the first venture fund dedicated to digital health, defines digital health as the space at the intersection of technology and healthcare. HealthXL shares this broad perspective and serves the entire and extensive field of digital health through its market intelligence platform and expert community.

DiMe focuses on digital medicine, the field of evidence-based digital health tools that measure and/or intervene in the service of health to support the practice of medicine broadly, including treatment, recovery, disease prevention, and health promotion for individuals and across populations. 

NODE.Health is a membership-based organization with a mission to bring the rigor of evidence-based science to digital medicine. NODE.Health builds on and explores the knowledge base now required to lead global healthcare systems and industry into the value-based era of digital transformation in health.

DTA is the industry association advancing the field of digital therapeutics (DTx). DTx products employ high quality software to deliver evidence-based therapeutic interventions that prevent, manage, or treat a broad spectrum of physical, mental, and behavioral conditions. 

These distinctions are intended to clarify, not complicate, the field of digital health. We agree with our FDA and NIH colleagues that:

Effective, unambiguous communication is essential for efficient translation of promising scientific discoveries into approved medical products. Unclear definitions and inconsistent use of key terms can hinder the evaluation and interpretation of scientific evidence and may pose significant obstacles to medical product development programs. 

We define these categories to support:

Specifics are invaluable

The digital health field is not yet served by a standard lexicon, and the many disciplines that comprise digital health are often separated by a common language. Anyone who has ever been part of a conversation about ‘validation’, for example, knows that every discipline has its own definition. 

This categorization framework goes beyond the existing definitions of digital health, digital medicine, and digital therapeutics to provide clarity with examples of products and product types.  

The digital health universe is rapidly expanding -- both in size and capabilities. Although this categorization is not intended to be wholly comprehensive, DiMe, DTA, HealthXL, and NODE.Health commit to regular framework updates to ensure it evolves with the industry and remains a valuable tool for all stakeholders. 

How to use this framework

This framework is not intended to assign hierarchy to the different digital health product categories. No category is more or less valuable to the advancement of health, healthcare, and/or health research; they are simply governed by different evidence and regulatory requirements. 

https://hxlbriefing.s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/Digital+Industry+Categorization.pdf
Download the full document HERE

In addition, users of this framework should not assume that digital health products have no degree of risk compared to digital medicine products or digital therapeutics. While the latter two are subject to higher evidence requirements and regulatory oversight due to greater clinical risk, commercial digital health tools may pose their own unique risks. 

For example, many digital health products may boast robust evidence despite its not being required, and the absence of such requirements can make it challenging to identify ‘digital health’ apps that have been proven effective. Similarly, there may be unintended consequences associated with the use of digital products without a robust body of evidence attesting to their safety, efficacy, and equality of performance.

Digital tools falling into the digital health category are currently governed by caveat emptor, or “buyer beware”. This is particularly challenging in an industry plagued by information asymmetry. 

Further, privacy and security concerns transcend this framework’s categorical boundaries of digital health, digital medicine, and digital therapeutics. Even when the necessary clinical evidence is available for a digital health product, other considerations such as security features, ethical approaches to data rights and governance, and economic feasibility should be considered.  

Why now?

There is a pressing need for further work to better characterize digital health products based on holistic assessments of risk.This is necessary to support trust in digital health, digital medicine, and digital therapeutics, and from there, realize their potential to improve health, healthcare, and health research.

By using this categorization framework, we trust that: patients will better understand what digital products they are using and for what purpose, clinicians will better leverage digital health products in practice and know how they relate to other treatments, payers will better understand the landscape of products available to patients and the type of value and clinical outcomes they should expect, and pharma will see the R&D requirements and commercial opportunities each offers. 

Wellness products deliver different outcomes than diagnostic products. Adherence products require different types of evidence and regulation than therapeutic products. Clinical decision support tools support clinicians differently than telehealth products. 

Clarity matters. And together our organizations are glad to be part of this conversation. 

Readers: We value your feedback, and encourage you to submit your comments on the framework here.

________

The Digital Medicine Society (DiMe) is a Massachusetts non-profit and professional society for individuals from all backgrounds working to advance digital medicine to optimize human health. 

The Digital Therapeutics Alliance (DTA) is a non-profit trade association with the mission of broadening the understanding and integration of clinically-evaluated digital therapeutics into healthcare to improve clinical and health economic outcomes.

HealthXL is the market intelligence platform and expert community for digital health. 

NODE.Health is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization dedicated to education, validation and dissemination of evidence based digital medicine. 

We can provide an introduction on your behalf so that you can contact them directly with any questions/queries on this topic. Simply click on the link below to request an introduction.

We can provide an introduction on your behalf so that you can contact them directly with any questions/queries on this topic. Simply click on the link below to request an introduction.

Request an Introduction

We can provide an introduction on your behalf so that you can contact them directly with any questions/queries on this topic. Simply click on the link below to request an introduction.

Request an Introduction

Ready to read more? HealthXL members can access the full peak of the report on the HealthXL Community Hub.

Not yet a member of HealthXL? Download your 11 page snapshot of the report.

Download your 11 page snapshot

Connect with peers and share insights

Don't miss out on the discussion of the latest insights and reports on digital health. Meet with peers and take a deep dive for 75 minutes. Unlike at webinars, you can freely exchange experiences and insights to solve challenges and design the future of DTx.

Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

DTx last mile delivery - HCPs and patients adoption

2nd November @ 11:45AM EDT

Join us in this informal conversation where we will discuss the main challenges around HCP and Patient adoption of DTx. Apply now to connect with peers and learn from fellow thought leaders in this space.

Featuring
Shrawan Patel
Shrawan Patel
Founder & MD, Strategy Health
Céline Ulmann
Céline Ulmann
Head of R&D Digital, Almirall
Featuring
Shrawan Patel
Shrawan Patel
Founder & MD, Strategy Health
Céline Ulmann
Céline Ulmann
Head of R&D Digital, Almirall
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

Tech Giants, Start-ups or Incumbents, who will disrupt healthcare?

4th November @ 11:30AM EDT

Join our Digital Health Meeting as discuss How do we define disruption in the healthcare industry? What is the ‘extinction event’ healthcare needs and why has it not happened yet? And what are the learnings from Tech Giants’ moves in healthcareApply now to join the conversation and share your thoughts on the topic.

Featuring
Amanda Goltz
Amanda Goltz
Principal, Business Development, Alexa Health & Wellness at Amazon
Anish Shindore
Anish Shindore
Head of NeuroTech & Open Innovation, Biogen
Featuring
Amanda Goltz
Amanda Goltz
Principal, Business Development, Alexa Health & Wellness at Amazon
Anish Shindore
Anish Shindore
Head of NeuroTech & Open Innovation, Biogen
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

Masterclass: How to get your DTx product reimbursed in the US?

4th November @ 11:45AM EDT

Are you a DTx company seeking reimbursement in the US? Then this masterclass is for you. Join us in this US-focused interactive masterclass led by Mike Pace, who will walk us through how to get your DTx product reimbursed in the US.

Featuring
Michael Pace
Michael Pace
Founder and President at PalmHealth.co
Featuring
Michael Pace
Michael Pace
Founder and President at PalmHealth.co
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

Masterclass: DiGa - Entering the digital health space in Germany

10th November @ 10:45AM EDT

Join us in this interactive masterclass led by Flying Health, as they discuss what you need to know to navigate the DiGa framework. Apply now to learn valuable insights from thought leaders in this space.

Featuring
Laura Nelde
Laura Nelde
Startup Relationship Manager at Flying Health
Len-Philipp Ortlepp
Len-Philipp Ortlepp
Junior Startup Relationship Manager, Flying Health
Featuring
Laura Nelde
Laura Nelde
Startup Relationship Manager at Flying Health
Len-Philipp Ortlepp
Len-Philipp Ortlepp
Junior Startup Relationship Manager, Flying Health

Are you a HealthXL Member? See the Full Report Here

Non-HealthXL Member? You can purchase the report HERE

HealthXL Digital Health Meetings

Want to join the discussion now?

Join our Digital Health Meetings and take a deep dive for 75 minutes into topics like digital therapeutics, patient support, telehealth, clinical trials, dermatology and many more. These Meetings are not regular webinars: No audience, no recording and no hiding behind a screen. You actively participate in a discussion to solve your present challenges and design the future of digital health. And with a free account on our Community Hub, you stay connected and up-to-date on the latest news and insights, allowing you to fully immerse yourself in the topic before, during and after.

Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

DTx last mile delivery - HCPs and patients adoption

2nd November @ 11:45AM EDT

Join us in this informal conversation where we will discuss the main challenges around HCP and Patient adoption of DTx. Apply now to connect with peers and learn from fellow thought leaders in this space.

Featuring
Shrawan Patel
Shrawan Patel
Founder & MD, Strategy Health
Céline Ulmann
Céline Ulmann
Head of R&D Digital, Almirall
Featuring
Shrawan Patel
Shrawan Patel
Founder & MD, Strategy Health
Céline Ulmann
Céline Ulmann
Head of R&D Digital, Almirall
Telemedicine & Virtual Care Delivery
Telemedicine & Virtual Care Delivery
Telemedicine & Virtual Care Delivery
Telemedicine & Virtual Care Delivery

Commercialisation models for Virtual Care in Respiratory Diseases

3rd November @ 11:45AM EDT

Join our Digital Health Meeting as we discuss commercialisation models for Virtual Care in Respiratory Diseases. Apply now to hear from fellow peers in this space and share your own thoughts and experiences on this topic.

Featuring
Peter Small
Peter Small
Chief Medical Officer, Hyfe
Caleb Bank
Caleb Bank
Product Marketing at NuvoAir
Featuring
Peter Small
Peter Small
Chief Medical Officer, Hyfe
Caleb Bank
Caleb Bank
Product Marketing at NuvoAir
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

Tech Giants, Start-ups or Incumbents, who will disrupt healthcare?

4th November @ 11:30AM EDT

Join our Digital Health Meeting as discuss How do we define disruption in the healthcare industry? What is the ‘extinction event’ healthcare needs and why has it not happened yet? And what are the learnings from Tech Giants’ moves in healthcareApply now to join the conversation and share your thoughts on the topic.

Featuring
Amanda Goltz
Amanda Goltz
Principal, Business Development, Alexa Health & Wellness at Amazon
Anish Shindore
Anish Shindore
Head of NeuroTech & Open Innovation, Biogen
Featuring
Amanda Goltz
Amanda Goltz
Principal, Business Development, Alexa Health & Wellness at Amazon
Anish Shindore
Anish Shindore
Head of NeuroTech & Open Innovation, Biogen
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)
Digital Therapeutics (DTx)

Masterclass: How to get your DTx product reimbursed in the US?

4th November @ 11:45AM EDT

Are you a DTx company seeking reimbursement in the US? Then this masterclass is for you. Join us in this US-focused interactive masterclass led by Mike Pace, who will walk us through how to get your DTx product reimbursed in the US.

Featuring
Michael Pace
Michael Pace
Founder and President at PalmHealth.co
Featuring
Michael Pace
Michael Pace
Founder and President at PalmHealth.co

What’s a Rich Text element?

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

We cannot guarantee that the content will display correctly while using Internet Explorer. To have the best browsing experience, please upgrade to Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Safari.